Why do bands always do this? The Tindersticks, a truly great band at moments, is reissuing much of their recorded output with better sound and (for most of the albums) a bonus disc of outtakes, demos, alternate versions, etc.
I’m all for reissues, but what about we loyal ‘Stickers who paid good money for the original versions of these CDs back in the day? I’m torn between the horror of paying for the same CDs twice and the horror of missing out on Tindersticks songs circa 1992-1996, when they were really on top of their game.
A quick crabwalk.com guide to the reissues:
– On their overall sound (quoth the prolific Stephen Thomas Erlewine): “Tindersticks were one of the most original and distinctive British acts of the ’90s, standing apart from both the British indie scene and the rash of Brit-pop guitar combos that dominated the UK charts. Where their contemporaries were often direct and to-the-point, Tindersticks were obtuse and leisurely, crafting dense, difficult songs layered with literary lyrics, intertwining melodies, mumbling vocals and gently melancholy orchestrations. Essentially, the group filtered the dark romanticism of Leonard Cohen, Ian Curtis and Scott Walker as filtered through the bizarre pop songcraft of Lee Hazlewood and the aesthetics of indie-rock. Though their music was far from casual listening, Tindersticks gained a dedicated cult following in the mid-’90s, beginning with their eponymous 1993 debut album, which was named Album of the Year by the Melody Maker.”
– If you don’t have the first album (dancing woman on cover) or the second (black-and-white tailoring photo on cover), the decision’s easy — buy them. (Both albums are called simply “Tindersticks” — hence the cover photo information.)
Popular opinion generally gives the first one the edge in quality. I think they’re both brilliant, but I’ll take the second. It’s got a sinewy, dark edge that is absolutely perfect for drinking alone. Plus, the bonus disc for the second album is the rare and much sought-out “Live at the Bloomsbury” show.
– The third album (“Curtains“) didn’t thrill me, although the promise of cleaned-up sound (the original was a bit muddy) is intriguing. And the bonus disc of b-sides looks promising.
– Album No. 4 is the Nenette et Boni soundtrack, which is hard to find in this country. Haven’t heard it, but Tindersticks are perfect for soundtrack work. (I’ve got another score of theirs, for Trouble Every Day, and it’s gorgeous.)
– The fifth album is Simple Pleasure, which I’ve never been able to find — I don’t know if it was ever released here or not.
The band also plans a best-of called “Working For The Man,” which, judging from the track listing, appears to be a good introduction. (For what it’s worth, there are two more recent Tindersticks LPs — the misdirectedly R&B-vibed Can Our Love… and the slight-return-to-form Waiting For The Moon.)
5 thoughts on “tindersticks reissues”
Comments are closed.
The Cure and Bowie have both done this recently. I suspect it’s mostly a money grab, as in “they’re no longer signed to our label, so we’re going to soak fans by recycling the songs we already own.”
Because, you *know*, I will be re-buying all my Cure and Bowie discs. I feel like such a tool.
You’ll feel even worse when compact discs become obsolete and are replaced by some new, better technological medium the size of postage stamps. I don’t know how many crabwalk readers have kids, but mine look at my vinyl records like they’re clovis points or something.
No one will force you to buy the re-issues. Generally, I don’t think of improved sound reissues as an exploitative money grab. There’s 2 underlying reasons for ’em, one better than the other. First, the not so good one: the initial CD issue of an album is rushed, with an LP mix used. This was notoriously true of the first wave of audio CDs. Second, the “better” reason, is that newer technology, whether it be, 20 bit, 24 bit, HDCD, DVDA or SACD weren’t available at the advent of the audio CD. It’s your choice. If you still like those recordings, buying the new versions may shed new light on them, equivalent to buying a new unheard CD. I’m not ashamed to say that I’m don’t it numerous times and have greatly enjoyed the results.
For the record, I realize no one will force me to buy the reissues. It’s less of a sound issue for me and more of a bonus track/rarities issue. I hate it when a band reissues an old album with two or three bonus tracks tagged on the end. Since I’ve already got the original CD, I don’t want to pay another $17 for 2-3 extra tracks.
I haven’t seen pricing on these Tindersticks reissues, and to be fair they’re offering a *lot* of bonus material — far more than 2-3 songs. But I in general don’t want to buy something again just to have the right to get a couple new tracks.
What some bands are doing is also adding some b-sides/remixes/live tracks etc to the re-issues, which makes them a bit more valuable to big fans.